User Rating: 4 out of 5 stars (13 ratings)
Nancy's Pizza
265 Ponce De Leon Ave Ne, Atlanta, GA
30308
Get directions
Cross Streets: Between Penn Ave NE and Argonne Ave NE
Neighborhood: Midtown Atlanta, GA
33.772435
-84.378553
1-10 of 10
Write a review
User Rating: 1 out of 5 starsNancy' pizza is awful awful awful. I went to the Buckhead location specifically looking for chicago style pizza (I have fond memories of Upper Crust at Lenox). My husband was not in a pizza mood, so he ordered a chicken sub. I ordered a small deep dish pizza. Our dinner cost $37 dollars, and I mistakenly wrote in a tip as you have to pay before receiving food. The sandwich came out after about 7 mins. We sat there for a few minutes waiting for my meal, but after 10 more mins, I told my husband to eat his sandwich before it got cold. He did so, and completed his meal with no sign of my pizza. After trying in vain to get the waitress to come to my table, I went up to the counter to inquire after my pizza. The apathetic counter woman condescendingly began explaining how deep dish pizza's take longer to cook than normal pizza. I retorted that while that was all well and good, I could not understand why they would not WAIT 10 MINUTES BEFORE COOKING THE SANDWICH on the same order as the pizza. Did they think a couple that came in together and sat together would not want to eat together? Or that I would ENJOY sitting there hungrily watching my husband eat his meal, and then he would ENJOY having sit and watch me eat mine twenty minutes later? The counter woman just shrugged. I asked to have my pizza put in a box and left fuming. When I got home, the pizza was also awful. The tomato sauce was too acidic, and I had to scrape it off. The pizza dough is OBVIOUSLY frozen, with a texture like a bad biscuit. I ate one piece sans sauce and threw the rest away. I then wrote a complaint e-mail to Nancy's Pizza Headquarters detailing my experience. They sent back a response saying the VP would contact me. Five days later and this hasn't happened. I WANT MY $43 DOLLARS BACK FOR THE WORST MEAL EXPERIENCE I HAVE HAD THIS YEAR! I plan to write bad reviews for this restaurant as often as I can until this happens. AWFUL! AWFUL! Save your money and do not frequent Nancy's Pizza!
User Rating: 3 out of 5 starsThis place is ok. It does taste like real Chicago style pizza without the traditional 45 minute wait like @ Gino's East in Chicago. It gets about 3.5 though good, it was a bit salty.
User Rating: 5 out of 5 starsi am from chicago and used to eat at nancy's pizza there many times and the one here is just as good same pizza .... it's good but still not as good as giordanos
User Rating: 5 out of 5 starsThe best Chicago style pizza I have ever had, outside of Chicago. We ordered from Nancy's twice while in Atlanta and had it delivered to our hotel room the staff was friendly and the delivery was timely. The second day that we ordered we got sandwiches and salad, the salad was great the sandwich was O.K., stick to the Deep Dish Pizza and you'll love it.
-
User Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
Went to this restaurant on a Friday night. The guy behind the counter looked as if he really didn't want to be there. He took my order while talking to someone which I thought was unprofessional.
We then asked for some cups to get water. Water is absolutely non-filtered; tasted like chlorine. We decided to get beers to try to get that taste out of our mouths. Got some Michelob Lights (since they only had a choice of FOUR beers and ALL of them on tap ... really). Got the beer and these had to be the most watered down beer ever ...
Got over that, but then we had been sitting there for 30 minutes and hadn't gotten our food yet (a deep dish pizza and a flat CHEESE pizza shouldn't be that hard to make). But for some reason the TWO (not just one) parties who order after us get their stuff before we do, one party he stops to actually talk to for 5 minutes while we wait for our food ... I stopped the waiter and asked him where our food was. He brings it out a minute later, apologizes and asks us do we want to 'compensate' us for the fact that they forgot our food.
Got a pitcher of Sam Adams ... worst tasting Sam Adams ever. Really. Tasted like metal.
Asked some random girl can we get a box. Here's were it actally went good, for a second. Brought the box out and dropped it until we looked at her ... and then she asked, "Oh, do you want me to put it in the box?" No ... we'll do your job and keep the tip. Which is what happened.
But, the deep dish pizza tasted good. Even though 2 pizzas cost $35.00 ... for a large meat lovers and a small cheese. Yes, $35.00. Stay home and order Pizza Hut. Don't go to the Buckhead one ... 
User Rating: 5 out of 5 starsThe ABSOLUTE BEST!: Now THIS is Chicago-style pizza at it's best.
-
User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Best pizza in atlanta: if you love chicago style, you will love Nancy's. service is great!
User Rating: 5 out of 5 starsbest pie in the ATL: best deep dish pie in atlanta...possibly the world!!!
User Rating: 4 out of 5 starsBest Chicago style pizza in the ATL!: Absolutely the best Chicago style pizza outside of the windy city. The deep dish pizza is excellent. I was totally going through (chicago pizza) withdrawl before I discovered Nancy's. If you are a fan of chicago deep dish then this is the place for you. The only complaint I have is the lack of dine-in space.
-
User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Looking forward to returning: This was with out a doubt the best deep dish pizza I have ever tasted in Atlanta or anywhere in the South. I just don't remember ever eating anything this close to a Chicago style pizza outside of Chicago. They deserve the praise. I just would like to see a largeer place with more sit down room for days when I don't want to go home.
Reviews 1-10 of 10
You Might Also Like
- Dailey's17 International Blvd, Atlanta, GA
- Alfredo's Italian Restaurant1989 Cheshire Bridge Rd Ne, Atlanta, GA
- California Pizza Kitchen264 19th St Nw, Atlanta, GA
- Ciao Bella309 Pharr Rd Ne, Atlanta, GA
Get Local Recommendations
- Find discussions about Nancy's Pizza in Atlanta
- Ask locals for a recommendation on Nancy's Pizza
More Search Options
- Search the web for Nancy's Pizza in Atlanta, GA
- Reviews of Atlanta Italian on Yelp.com
-
Local Resources:
-
Advertiser Resources:
-
Atlanta Resources:
Comments (1)
Hey there, buddy. Chicago Deep Dish pizza actually takes 30 to 45 to cook. Oh, and the price... eat at Uno's in Chi Town and see how much you spend. $35.00 is pretty good for two pizzas much less one reg pizza and one deep dish. 2 pizzas at Pizza Hut will cost you more depending on the toppings, and they are assembly line pizzas. As far as watered down beer goes... Mich Lights are basically water anyway. Sam Adams is a close second. Try ordering some real beer.