A time-honored tradition on the island is a trip to Murdick's candy store. The shop has been selling high-quality fudge...
Website: eventseeker.com
Phone: (508) 627-8047
Cross Streets: Between Winter St and Mayhew Ln
21 N Water St Edgartown, MA 02539 661.34 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.5 37 reviews
5 stars for the fudge. 2 stars for the attitude of the person working there. I went here twice. The first time I went, I was simply curious to try their fudge. I bought 1 piece of fudge which... More
Got fudge here a few years ago and it was delicious, so on our recent trip back to Martha's Vineyard we stopped at the Edgartown store and got some. It was awful...crusty and hard. Nothing like I... More
I'm not like a fudge expert by any means so I have no frame of reference regarding the quality of their fudge, so take this review with a grain of salt. The place is fine. They have a decent... More
I want to give Murdick's 5 stars... the Fudge is good and the place is iconic on the Vineyard. BUT for these prices, there should be more than 5 small pieces of pecan in a slice of chocolate... More
I like to watch the Murdick Fudgemasters make the rich creamy velvety fudge by hand using an oak paddle-technique to mold a perfect 30-lb. slab on the marble table. Murdick's offers about a dozen... More
