Jesus R.04/04/24At proud papas, what you see is what you get. I mean that in a good way. The pizza is great, their chicken parm is great, and their calamari is the best I've had in a while. I've read some... More
Jay C.02/24/23Ordered 2 salads via Uber Eats. Easy enough I figured. Completely wrong salads were delivered. And they were $21 each!!!! Called and they really seemed like they didn't give a s**t. I drive... More
Kosta M.02/10/23Food was ok definitely not the best slice around. Service is terrible no customer service everyone is on their cellphones and they don't even talk to customers coming in. I ordered 4 slices and... More
Amy A.12/08/22Always good food... friendly service, quick delivery . There pizza is great i love it because it's always soft, smaller pieces and the one with chicken cutlet is great too. Also try their buffalo... More
Brandon S.09/16/19As a New Yorker, it almost feels like a sin to say this about a New Jersey Pizzeria, but Proud Papa's has some of the best pizza I've had. Specifically, their buffalo chicken pizza is to die... More