Gab B.04/10/24omg the onion bagel was amazing. i eould absolutely go here again. it was affordable and they had so many bagel and cream cheese option. go here!!!!! More
Pete G.05/14/24Several times a year, I bring people to New York to experience the city. I always include a stop at Bagels on the Square because you need a true New York bagel experience, and this is a great... More
Jim P.03/22/24Meh... It did seem like my cinnamon raisin bagel was a leeeeetale stale. Definitely didn't seem like it was made that morning, when I walked in at 10:30am on a Sunday. $1.64 Wouldn't be my... More
Rachel N.01/30/24These were very sub par bagels, bagels that do not really deserve to occupy real estate in New York City. The bagels themselves were flavorless, and had the texture of bread. The inside of the... More
Phil H.12/09/23UGH! I'll get right to it. No beating around the bush here. Bagels sucked. Can I say sucked and not violated TOS? I started with an everything with cream cheese, I ordered it un-toasted cause... More