Calandra B.04/06/24Great service and good food. Unfortunately there are a lot of large parties on the weekends and it can get loud. No longer a good date night spot on the weekend. More
Alexandra F.01/28/24How do you have lobster in your restsurant name, but overcook lobsters? This food was so gross. I ordered a lobster tail and strip steak, medium rare, and my god. The steak looked boiled - like it... More
john d.04/21/243rd visit 4/21/24 ,for an anniversary lunch with the Mrs. . Previously we were part of large family groups. Service is polite, facilities clean, comfortable, mixed seating arrangements. Very large... More
Ebony E.01/16/24Authentic City Island cuisine... while there are many options here, we dined here, not once, but twice because we liked the decor, chatter of people, and the friendliness of the staff. It wasn't... More
Tony C.01/10/24It's always a fun time dining at city island lobster house. My family has been gong here for a long time and we always go home satisfied. We always order some combination of the broiled combo... More