User Rating: 4 out of 5 stars (14 ratings)
Nicky's Restaurant
- (914) 997-6951
- Menu
91 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains, NY
10601
Get directions
Cross Streets: Between Quarropas St and Mitchell Pl
Share your photos of Nicky's Restaurant. Upload now.
Own this business? Get guaranteed top placement.
| Hours: | 11:30am - 2:00am |
| Categories: | Pizza, Seafood Restaurants, Italian Restaurants, Restaurants, Sandwiches |
| Parking: | Street |
| Specialities: | People Watching, Dim Lights |
| Amenities: | TV, Late Night Menu, Satellite, Sports |
| Cuisine: | Italian, Pizza |
| Ambiance: | Casual, Romantic, Family Friendly |
| Feature: | Late Night, Private Rooms |
| Reservations Policy: | None |
| Smoking: | No Smoking |
| Dress Code: | None |
| Price: | $2 - $12 |
Recent Reviews
1-3 of 13 Write a review
User Rating: 1 out of 5 starsI just ordered a sandwich from Nickyâs and had to let the world know about this pathetic enterprise. I ordered the Italian combo, which is listed on the menu at about $9 â a little pricey, but people in my office rave about the pizza, so I went ahead. The woman behind the counter asked whether I wanted lettuce/tomato, onions, oil/vinegar, or anything else on it. I didnât even stop to thinkâ¦I said, Sure, Iâll have everything with hot peppers. She called the order in, punched her cash register, and handed me a check for $13.46. Huh? Turns out that THEY CHARGE FOR LETTUCE AND FOR TOMATO AND FOR OIL AND FOR VINEGARâ¦$0.50 per item. Thirteen and half bucks for an Italian combo!?!? OK, this is the most Iâve ever paid for a sandwich Iâve ordered everywhere, but letâs give it a shotâ¦maybe it will be the best ever. I give her a twenty, she hands back $6.50. OK, itâs only four cents short, that ainât gonna change my life, but at least ask me, ya know? Ten minutes later, out comes my wrapped sandwich. I thank her and head back to the office. And here comes the clincher. No, itâs not that the three tomato slice were so thin that I could see through them. No, itâs not that the sandwich had maybe one-quarter pound of tasteless cold cuts on it. Itâs this: IT WAS SLATHERED IN MAYONNAISE! What self-respecting Italian puts mayo on an Italian combo? Iâm stunned, and after scraping away the mayo, and therefore most of the bread, and then finshing this pathetic excuse for a sandwich, Iâm hungry. So the moral of the story: stick to the pizza.
-
User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
I live right down the street from this place, and I am glad I do. Great Pizza!
User Rating: 5 out of 5 starsNicky's is fantastic. I found this place while stuck at work late one night several years back and have been going ever since. The wait staff remembers all faces and what you usually order. Do we here "Cheers" here?
I highly recommend the the White Pizza and Antipasto with Gorganzola crumbles.
Reviews 1-3 of 13 View 10 at a time
Show All
You Might Also Like
- Famous Pizza & Souvlaki Rest10 N Water St, Greenwich, CT
- Pizza Hut39 Marble Ave, Pleasantville, NY
- Famous Famiglia Pizzeria48 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains, NY
- The Original Pappas Pizza201 Main St, Stamford, CT
Get Local Recommendations
- Find discussions about Nicky's Restaurant in White Plains
- Ask locals for a recommendation on Nicky's Restaurant
More Search Options
- Search the web for Nicky's Restaurant in White Plains, NY
- Reviews of White Plains Pizza on Yelp.com
-
Local Resources:
-
Advertiser Resources:
-
White Plains Resources:
Comments (1)
Is Nicky's strickly pizza or do they also have a sit down meal menu?