Serving Suffern Since 1967, we offer friendly family atmosphere and wide variety of food options at a convenient...
Website: slicelife.com
Phone: (845) 357-7767
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Route 59 and RT-59/Hemion Rd/Campbell Ave
Pickup · Delivery
22 Route 59 Montebello, NY 10901 471.76 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.0 40 reviews
The best!!! Staff is incredibly nice and they beat every Italian place with prices in a big way. The food is delicious. We get family meals and the chicken Marsala was jammed with tender chicken... More
I tried a selection of sandwiches from Nicky's for an event, and the group was satisfied with the selection. Ordering online was easy, and they have a wide selection of sandwiches. I personally... More
Nicky's used to be the place to go but a recent Chicken parm dinner was possibly the worst I have had. After requesting and getting a replacement order the dish was the same. Chicken was thin,... More
Chicken Parm dinner was pretty bad. Portions were huge though so that's a plus. But it was both overcooked and undercooked. Extremely unappetizing but luckily I'm starving. Just gonna put the... More
Past several weeks I have ordered meals for my weekly Rotary Club meetings from Nicky's. The twenty or so members give Nicky's a thumbs up. Pizzas, salads, wraps, trays of meatballs, eggplant... More
