Rob H.03/01/24I recently visited Mill Basin Bagel Cafe and, overall, I would say that my experience was average. The bagels were decent, but I couldn't help feeling that there was room for improvement. On the... More
Stacey O.04/12/24There are 2 things that bother me about this place. Every week their prices change. What I mean is a bagel with vegetable cream cheese (which they call fancy cream cheese) goes up every time I... More
Dana A.10/22/23You'd think paying the price you do for flavored cream cheese they'd actually put some cream cheese on the bagel. This is completely empty in the middle like they smeared a swipe of cream cheese... More
Philip Z.12/31/23The bagels are tasty but small. And the employees are miserable. Cashiers make eye contact only with their phones, and NEVER greet or thank customers. Food preparers are not to be questioned if... More
Jay M.12/03/23I'm so tired of this place. Everyone is exceptionally polite, except for one guy behind the counter, who always happens to end up taking my order. He takes the order so confidently, but then... More