Lauren S.04/05/24I've only been here a couple of times, but my oh my, does this spot hit the spot! (Pun intended, I think?) I would LOVE to go all out and get a bagel sandwich with lox, cream cheese, and all of... More
Jackie O.03/25/24Excellent service when we call ahead in the morning! Always quick and on point. The healthy bagel, everything, cinnamon raisin, and egg everything are so fresh and tasty! More
Barry T.11/21/22Been putting off writing this review for far too long. While we live in North Merrick and there are quite a few bagel places between us and Bagelman, centrally located on Merrick Ave (next to... More
Deborah K.02/14/236 people in back kitchen doing who knows what with 2 girls up front who didn't know how to ring up orders. I ordered an egg everything bagel with cream cheese that has no egg in the bagel and had... More
Jennifer A.07/09/21I come here for bagels sometimes after my hot yoga classes or when I'm around and need an early breakfast. The prices are fair and the bagels are big. I normally get walnut raisin cream cheese in... More