Local Search by Yahoo! Local
User Rating: 4 out of 5 stars (20 ratings)

Stefano's Pizzeria

258 State St, Carthage, NY 13619 Get directions Cross Streets: Between Canal St and N Mechanic St/S Mechanic St
43.976976 -75.610448
Own this business? Get guaranteed top placement.
Hours:Open 7 Days A Week
Categories:Catering Services, Carry Out & Take Out, Restaurants, Pizza
Payment:Diners Club, American Express, MasterCard, Visa
Specialities:Daily Specials, Pizza, Catering Available, Calzones, Wing's, We Deliver, Subs, Pasta, Cold Subs, Eat In Or Pick-Up Only, Family Special, Catering & Party Trays, Calzoni & Rolls, Buffalo Style Wings, Beer & Wine
Brands:$1 Off A Large Pizza, All Day Specials, Appetizers, Hot Subs, Not Valid With Any Other Specials, Small Parties Up To 50 People, Soups & Salads, Special Of The Day, Specialty Pizzas, Specialty Sicilian Dinners
Other Contact Info:Fax: (315) 493-1553
Recent Reviews 1-3 of 16 Write a review
  1. User Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
    by dineoutpro
    02/14/2009
    Of all the restaurants in Carthage, this seems to be the most popular. I don't see why though, great service but thats about it. I have eaten here between ten and fifteen times, because like i said it's the most popular place in Carthage, but never had a meal that was enjoyable. Pizza is alright, wings are ok, pasta is so so. The best meal i had was a sparerib sandwich, it was frozen, makes it hard to mess up. Well if i write much more nobody will want to read this. People of Carthage get it together, go out for dinner and not just around the corner, i know there isn't much in that town but within twenty miles there is plenty.
    Was this review helpful? 00 Report Abuse | Subscribe to dineoutpro's reviews
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
  2. User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    by A Person Who Knows Food
    11/05/2008
    Excellent everytime I have been. I love the food and the atmosphere. I have children and not all children can be calmed with crackers, as previously suggested. They did their best to accomodate my 3 yr old first and keep her happy and I as well.
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
  3. User Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
    by They are out there.
    08/23/2008
    In August 08, My family met at the resturant for dinner. Some of us had eaten the pizza and enjoyed. It was a large party (10).The first complaint was that the room was so full of echos that it was hard to talk to each other at the table because you heard every else's conversations.A child at another table spent most of the time yelling and screaming. I know the workers had nothing to do with that but they could have brought the kid some crackers to shut him up! The waitress seem very surprised when I ask for the bread that was listed as part of the meal. She brought one slice each and we had to insist strongly before we got more! After the fact, I found that the place offered a Senior discount but we were not offered that even though 8 of the 10 were visably over 65. The last and biggest problem...I ordered Manicotti. The sauce tasted like they poured tomato soup over the top and added a ton of cheese.Come on now...Isn't part of Italian food, the spice? It was terrible.I suggest you drive a few miles to Watertown and go to a real Italian Resturant.
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
Reviews 1-3 of 16 View 10 at a time Show All

Find nearby

Show businesses on a map:

You Might Also Like

More Recommendations

Get Local Recommendations

More Search Options

Carthage City Guide > Food & Dining > Catering > Stefano's Pizzeria