Michelle D.05/05/21Food is fresh and hot! Very good pizza with lots of flavor. Pizzeria is right in town of Newark. Grab your pizza and enjoy the view of the canal. Customer service was great. Walked in and ordered... More
Michelle G.03/21/24We just spent $180.00 on an online order. I called because I wanted to be sure they delivered plates and napkins and was told they didn't have plate. Completely unacceptable!! More
Heather F.09/26/21In town for work at nuclear outage and decided to try this little place. Pizza was good and the fried mushrooms yummy. Didn't care for the strange taste of the soda from the fountain but could've... More
Becky B.06/29/17It was mediocre at best there are alot better pizza places down the road the sad truth of it is that i will never get back the 45 minutes i spent there so in short if you like stale and nasty... More
Brad L.11/25/08Previous to my most recent visit, the last time I ate at Pontillo's was in high school! This week though, I came home to visit from San Francisco, where, I will add, it's damn near impossible to... More