Serving Interlaken for over a decade, Cayuga Lake Creamery is the go-to place when it comes to ice creams and other...
Website: cayugalakecreamery.com
Phone: (607) 532-9492
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of State Route 89 and Holton Beach Rd
Pickup
8421 State Route 89 Interlaken, NY 14847 2317.04 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.0 138 reviews
I wish they were open during winter! There's something about how they make their ice cream that is quite special. One must be the quality of dairy and ingredients they use. They don't put in... More
Cayuga Lake Creamery was a great ice cream stop. They have a large selection of homemade ice cream and they have hard, soft, custard and sundaes to choose from. They also have some savory food... More
I know good quality ice cream when I see it. I had to try Cayuga Lake Creamery when I saw them at the Trumansburg farmers market. After trying their Lemon Sorbet and Purple Cow ice cream, I knew I... More
Rich, creamy flavors that you won't find elsewhere, ample seating and parking (there's a second lot down a little hill), and a bathroom inside with more tables. Scoops are average size so can can... More
Beware that if you come in a van they will not serve you - even if there are only 6 of in your group Beyond disappointed to have waited inline for 15 minutes for us to go up to the window for... More
