Local Search by Yahoo! Local
User Rating: 45 out of 5 stars (4 ratings)

Sarah L Defelice Pizza House

611 Myrtle Ave, Punxsutawney, PA 15767 Get directions Cross Streets: Between Sycamore St and Chestnut St
40.946359 -78.982938

Share your photos of Sarah L Defelice Pizza House. Upload now.

Own this business? Get guaranteed top placement.
Categories:Carry Out & Take Out, Restaurants, Pizza

Know more details about this business? Click here to share them with your neighbors.

Recent Reviews 1-3 of 3 Write a review
  1. User Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
    by horsetheif
    04/23/2009
    This pizza was a big let down, I heard from some that this was the "original" but it was very greasy and the service was not very friendly. The crust was good but the center of the pizza was not cooked the entire way through. Laskas Pizza has it all over this place
    Was this review helpful? 01 Report Abuse | Subscribe to horsetheif's reviews
    Comments (1)
    horsetheif - 05/08/09
    I agree if this was the original then Laskas perfected it. We waited over an hour for the pizzas and they were doughy not cooked the entire way through ewww
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
  2. User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    by snowflake
    10/04/2006
    Sarah's Grease Slappers: Oh yes, that is what we called Sarah Defelice's pizza, "grease slappers" and man, they are good! Great price, great pizza, and as for the service, be patient. During the time that Sarah was in full operation, you could wait 2 - 3 hours for a pizza, but the pizza were fantastic, sweet sauce, yellow/white cheese, pepperoni, thin crust...and excess grease.... I live for the grease slapper. In fact, for whatever the reason, it taste better the next day after it has been sitting out overnight! Many times, I have eaten Sarah's pizza for breakfast. This is indeed the breakfast of champions!
    Was this review helpful? 10 Report Abuse | Subscribe to snowflake's reviews
    Comments (1)
    tori15767 - 08/22/07
    Its too bad she died...now its good, but not the same
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
  3. User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    by nicdogg616
    04/09/2006
    Pick up a grrreat pie!!: We've been going to this place as long as i can remember... the painting of the old house (of which half still remains) hangs in the bank in punxy. Hand made everything, old fashioned thin crust out of a hot over (not the conveyor kind either) makes this the best pizza in the WORLD... much less the town! Their cheap and i could eat a pie myself (and have) so be sure to get plenty... on my way over Easter to get this pizza all the way from Niagara Falls,NY... Can't wait!!! The tradition lives on!!!
    Was this review helpful? 00 Report Abuse | Subscribe to nicdogg616's reviews
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
Reviews 1-3 of 3

Find nearby

Show businesses on a map:

You Might Also Like

More Recommendations

Get Local Recommendations

More Search Options

Punxsutawney City Guide > Food & Dining > Restaurants > Carry Out & Take Out > Sarah L Defelice Pizza House