Treat your taste buds to a scrumptious pizza at Pizza Cottage. This restaurant is known for serving a variety of pizzas...
Website: eventseeker.com
Phone: (740) 366-5747
Pickup
969 Mt Vernon Rd Newark, OH 43055 30.76 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.5 48 reviews
A must try when in Newark! Grew up going to Pizza Cottage out at Buckeye Lake and was thrilled to realize that the Pizza Cottage was in Newark. Restaurant was very clean and tons of seating,... More
2 small pizzas and a meatball sub = 50 bucks - are you insane? Quality of food = average Price = outrageous. Meatball sub was mostly empty bread and pizzas were fine - nothing special,... More
Pizza was decent but the salads left a lot to be desired. I ordered the Garden Salad and opted to not eat it since it was primarily white and brown. Drive thru pickup is convenient enough. Really... More
Just the best pizza in Newark Ohio bar none! Great Parmesan taste! People either seem to love it or hate it but I love it! Toppings are always fresh no canned stuff, and plentiful! More
I don't know what happened in the last year but it's gone down hill. I used to order here regularly and I just tried again. Got 2 large BLTs and there was basically no lettuce and barely any mayo.... More
