Authentic NY/East coast Pizza made from family recipes by a true New Yorker! Our dough is made fresh daily using only...
Website: pizzerianewyork.com
Phone: (614) 862-4743
Cross Streets: Between Hill Rd N and Diley Rd
833 Hill Rd N Pickerington, OH 43147 12.73 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.5 85 reviews
The big mistake I made all those years ago was driving past this place, assuming it wasn't designed for the normal family. That, mainly because the bar next door was always flooded with the rowdy... More
Pepperoni Pizza On a scale of 1 to 10 I'd give this a 5. Don't expect it to taste like New York Pizza. New York Pizza More
This small business doesn't care about customers. They use cheap ingredients, and cut corners wherever possible. Their pizza is barely edible, and the owner expects to sit on her heiny all day... More
Great Pizza. Not like the usual thin crust Columbus-style. Friendly and fast service. More
Pizza was DELICIOUS! Everyone we encountered were super friendly! Definitely will make the hour trip back to try it again! More
