100% handmade New York pizza. We are widely regarded as one of the best New York pizza in Columbus, OH and iconic...
Website: anthonys-pizzeria.com
Phone: (614) 231-6628
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Pleasant Ridge Ave and E Main St
602 Pleasant Ridge Ave Bexley, OH 43209 3.45 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.0 140 reviews
Wow. House Favorite slice is amazing. Moving day, just looking for good pizza, this is a quintessential pizzeria lil' place on a small college campus, sooo good. The vibe is young & fun, been... More
First, let's dispense with the obvious. The pizza here is superb. Great, fresh ingredients skillfully prepared. But that's just the beginning. The ambiance is relaxed and folksy. If the... More
Perfect Deep Dish once again. We order it well done and it turned out just that. Delivered in 40 minutes, so its not a quick pie. More
My pizza arrived not fully cooked and inedible. No apology from the restaurant when I reached out via Facebook. Just told me I'd have to take it up with Uber Eats. More
I'm so glad i gave Anthony's Pizzeria a try because I was thoroughly impressed. This was an amazing pizza and it really surprised me just how good it was. The pizza was perfectly thin and was so... More
