Home Made Pies & Cheesecakes Daily Since 1930. Hours: 8:00am to 6:00pm, Monday through Saturday. Closed Sundays. Fruit...
Website: mehaffiespies.com
Phone: (937) 253-1163
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Linden Ave and S Smithville Rd
3013 Linden Ave Dayton, OH 45410 63.47 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.0 36 reviews
This place is INCREDIBLE! Everything we have tried so far has been a solid 10/10. On top of that, they have the kindest staff around. So far we have had the apple pie, coconut creme, peanut butter... More
Pies are much smaller now...crust was not as good as I remember. Oh....someone else bought the shop. $10 for little thin pies...nope...not going back. More
I think there is a saying, 'even bad pie is better than no pie! We this is fantastic pie. All different flavors I got blueberry. After the first bite I only ate 1/3 of the single slice I... More
If you like strawberry-rhubarb pie, try Mehaffie's. Soft crust sprinkled with a dusting of sugar and the filling was a great balance of sweet (not too sweet) and tart. If the other pies are this... More
Amazing service! Amazing people! Very friendly! They have an amazing collection of pies. We got plain cheesecake. No doubt it was amazingly flavored! But it was very rich. A little more crust... More
