My husband and I are from Ohio and went to Casey's because it was recommended by the owner of Mariner Yacht Sales. We were only in town for one night, purchasing a boat. We LOVED Casey's. The food was outstanding and there was ALOT of it. We had lunch the next day with the "doggie bag"! The service was excellent and they even let us watch the Cleveland Cavaliers on the TV. If we are ever in New Buffalo again, we most certainly will eat at Casey's.

Sunday Feb. 21 2010 was my son's birthday and he was a little under the weather and when my and I asked him what he wanted for dinner he asked if we could get carry out from Casey's. We live in southern La Porte county so the drive is about 30 min. I picked up the food and when we were getting it ready we discovered the order was totally wrong. I called to let them know what had happened and the person who answered the phone acted like they could care less and never offerd to make it right. We used to go there all the time but I'll never step foot in that place again. I wish you could take stars away.