Joshrooney R.11/21/23Basing my review on my most recent order, not my cumulative experience. Pizza's were excellent, large three topping and a Sicilian. Cheese was of good consistency, crust was light and thin, sauce... More
Danny F.12/05/23I've heard great reviews from people about this place. Thought I had it at a party and did not like it but could not remember if it was this place or somewhere else. So, I thought I give it a try... More
Ty D.06/23/23Way overpriced pizza! $40 for an everything pizza is a rip off. One thing that is consistent is that they always unevenly distribute the toppings on the pizza. There's much better NY style... More
gs h.02/19/24Valentinos Pizza is a Southbay landmark. Years ago, it was the best Brooklyn style pizza anywhere. Sadly, the last decade or so the quality has been spotty and sporadic. The prices have gone... More
Lou C.07/24/23!!! TIP SHAMERS !!! I have ONE rule and that is I do not return to a place that tip shames at the point of sale. The NYC slices here are better than average, but a rule is a rule and I will not... More