Local Search by Yahoo! Local
User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars (6 ratings)

La Fornaretta Restaurant

455 Main St, Newcastle, CA 95658 Get directions Cross Streets: Between Cypress St and Page St
38.87482 -121.133582

Share your photos of La Fornaretta Restaurant. Upload now.

About:EATING PLACE
Categories:Italian Restaurants, Restaurants
Year Established:2007
Recent Reviews 1-3 of 6 Write a review
  1. User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    by spar50
    12/18/2008
    LET ME TELL YOU A STORY IT WAS 1972 WE WERE MOVING FROM "DAILY CITY,SAN FRAN" TO "TERRA LINDA,MARIN CO" HAULING BOXES ALL DAY MY SISTERS AND I,STARVING MY DAD SAYS "YOU GUYS HUNGRY" WE DROPED THE BOXES.WE DROVE A SHORT DISTANCE TO A SMALL LOCAL MARKET "SCOTTY'S MARKET" NEXT TO THE MARKET WAS A "PIZZA JOINT" AS MY DAD SAID,LITTLE DID WE KNOW THAT THIS "PIZZA JOINT" WAS GOING TO BE AN EXPERIENCE OF A LIFE TIME.WE HAD TO WAIT OUT SIDE BECAUSE THE PLACE WAS PACKED AND IT WAS A WEEK DAY,HOW DO REMEMBER THIS,I HAD TO GOTO MY NEW SCHOOL THE NEX DAY "SANTA MARGARITA ELL".STANDING IN LINE I DECIDED TO LOOK IN THE WINDOW,I SAW TWO GUYS TOSSING PIZZA DOUGH IN THE AIR,I SMILED,LOOKED AT MY SISTERS AND SAID "LOOK AT THIS" ALL WE COULD DO IS SMILE AT EACH OTHER,WE GOT A TABLE LOOKED AT THE MENU WE AGREED ON THE #9 (PEPERONI & SCALLIONS) ONE OF THE "GUYS" WHO TOSSED THE PIZZA DOUGH BROUGHT OUR PIZZA TO OUR TABLE,HE INTRODUCED HIM SELF AS NICOLE LOCOCO "Lo Coco's pizzaria" NICOLE AND FILLIPE WERE THE OWNERS(SPELLING OF FIRST NAMES MIGHT NOT BE CORRECT).I TOOK MY FIRST BITE WOW THE CHRUNCH FROM THE DOUGH THE SAUCE AND PEPERONI,CHESE ABSOLUTELY THE BEST PIZZA ON THE FACE OF THIS PLANET,WAIT A MINUET I'AM 8YRS OLD 3RD GRADE WHAT THE HELL DO I KNOW ABOUT PIZZA.I GRADUATED FROM TERRA LINDA HS IN 1984 AND IM TELLING YOU THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA EVER!!!.................BUT WAIT IT'S DEC 12 2008,I NOW LIVE IN "AUBURN CA" WITH THE REST OF MY FAMILY SCATTERED AROUND TOWN,WHEN MY SISTER CALLED ME AND SAID "YOUR NOT GOING TO BELIVE THIS" I SAID "WHAT ,WHAT" SHE SAID "THE DAUGHTER OF ONE OF THE LoCoco BROTHERS OPENED UP A SHOP IN "NEW CASTLE CA" JUST SOUTH OF AUBURN,I WENT THERE THAT NIGHT I COULDN'T BELIVE IT SHE HAD THE DOUGH RECIPE AND THE SAUCE,THE PIZZA CAME TO OUR TABLE,I TOLD MY SON KELSY "DON'T TOUCH IT JUST SMELL" AND SAID TO HIM "THIS IS HOW YOU ARE GOING TO MEASURE PIZZA FROM THIS DAY FORWARD NOW PICK UP A SLICE AND HAVE A BITE" HIS EYES OPENED WIDE,SAUCE WAS HOT HE COUDN'T SAY ANYTHING,THEN HE SAID "DAD YOUR RIGHT" HE'S 13 BY THE WAY...............WHEN I SAID THAT "IT WAS AN EXPERIENCE OF A LIFE TIME" I MEAN IT GO TRY IT,YOU'LL LOVE IT THE PIZZARIA IS CALLED "LA FORNARETTA"
    Was this review helpful? 11 Report Abuse | Subscribe to spar50's reviews
    Comments (1)
    David H - 10/23/09
    This review appears to be for an entirely different restaurant in an entirely different location, not to mention that it is from an experience in 1972 which is hardly relevant to 2009!
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
  2. User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    by Shelene R
    03/03/2008
    Excellent! If you want to get out of the city and enjoy the feel of a small town without sacrificing taste then this is the place for you. I live in Sacramento and it was worth the drive. I didn't have to worry about finding a parking spot or even paying for parking. There was no traffic, the food was wonderful, even the bread they bring you is superb and tastes completely homemade. I made a reservation, but even if you have to wait a little, you can always get a glass of wine and wait out front. They project clips of Italy and classic movies out front on the building wall.
    Was this review helpful? 40 Report Abuse | Subscribe to Shelene R's reviews
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
  3. User Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    by Gourmet Jay
    12/21/2007
    This place is great! Just what the foothills needed as far as Italian goes. I stumbled on it one day for lunch. I was doing some work on my property in Newcastle and remembered there was a mexican restaurant in that location. I went for lunch and found it had been replaced with an italian retsaurant. I gave it a try and I was immediatly hooked. I excitedly came home and told my wife that we just had to go for dinner one evening. She became hooked also. Their red sauce is the best I have ever had and their seafood specials on weekends are a real treat. The bread is to die for. I think its the same as they use for the pizza. The desserts are equally as good. We have had nothing but excellent food and outstanding service. We are addicted to this place and if you like truly authentic italian dishes you will be too.
    Was this review helpful? 30 Report Abuse | Subscribe to Gourmet Jay's reviews
    Comment on Review
    Y! Updates An Update about your review will be shared via Yahoo! Updates Manage who sees your Updates
Reviews 1-3 of 6 View 10 at a time Show All

Find nearby

Show businesses on a map:

Get Local Recommendations

More Search Options

Newcastle City Guide > Food & Dining > Restaurants > Italian > La Fornaretta Restaurant