Kristin C.04/03/24Good service, clean, fresh food, plenty of parking (but this place does tend to get busy). Pizza is the star of the show, and my favorite is the BLT pizza. It's on a white cracker crust and just... More
Mary B.09/10/22This Pizza Cottage is located off Hill road and Refugee road in Pickerington. We stopped into this location after supporting a friend's son during the rivalry football game between North vs... More
Chelsea W.12/12/22Great pizza and friendly staff! The quality is good whether eating in or taking out. They have the basics as well as a variety of specialty pizzas. The cauliflower crust is awesome with a thin,... More
Shawn L.07/21/21While visiting family they brought me to Pizza Cottage for lunch. They clearly come in a lot bc waiter, Eric, knew them and their orders. He was a good waiter so explained their loyalty.... More
Nancy C.09/06/23Never saw such a greasy pizza. Gross. Service is ok. Won't be going back. Also don't order mushrooms on your pizza unless you love the canned variety. More