We're Right Under Your Nose. Since 1989 Mustachio's Pizza has been serving Kenmore, Tonawanda, North Buffalo, Riverside,...
Website: mustachiospizza.net
Phone: (716) 874-8909
Cross Streets: Between Fowler Ave and W Girard Blvd
Pickup · Delivery
2701 Elmwood Ave Buffalo, NY 14217 296.38 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.0 113 reviews
There is a ton of good pizza in Buffalo, and Mustachio's still manages to stand our. I miss their Parkside location. We ordered in advance and ate at their counter. It's not a dine-in place,... More
Tried out Mustachio's earlier today, and I'm happy I did. I ordered 2 chicken finger subs for myself and my daughter, and they were fantastic. They put huge chicken fingers on the sub and the... More
The first thing that struck me was the bright yellow boxes. Just... noteworthy. As to food: -pizza was good. Flavor was full, cheese was great, cupped pepperoni was solid, toppings were very... More
Great pizza! I ordered two slices. They were served fast and hot. The staff was friendly. Very small inside so get them to go like I did. I was really impressed with the slices. I can't wait to... More
Incredible food, the staff is always welcoming and friendly, and the place is immaculate and spotless. They even comped me a large pizza when I made the mistake of ordering the wrong thing online.... More
