My boyfriend loves Oley's, but I have no idea why. I've tried giving it a chance over and over again because he loves it so much and always wants to eat there... I've tried the double crust pizza, thin crust, pizza roll, and an Italian beef sub and have not liked any of them... they just seem to be of poor quality ingredients, the sauce is bland, and it's just all around not good... Not to mention how disappointed I was when I first moved to Fort Wayne from Chicago I asked people where I could get Chicago style stuffed pizza and everyone told me Oley's but it's not even close! Not at all! If people think this compares to Chicago stuffed pizza then they've obviously never had stuffed pizza from Chicago before. Chicago stuffed pizza has the yummiest sauce ON TOP of the cheese and much better ingredients, cheese, crust, and everything! The Italian beef I just tried is still sitting here next to me and it smells like feet! I would give it one star, but I gave it an extra star since my boyfriend likes it so much.

• Reply
• Add to your collection