At Poppy's we specialize in quality NY style Pizza. Our handmade dough and sauce come from a 72 year old Brooklyn recipe...
Website: orderpoppyspizza.com
Phone: (239) 689-5660
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Old McGregor Blvd and McGregor Blvd
Pickup · Delivery
15501 Old McGregor Blvd Fort Myers, FL 33908 933.86 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.0 105 reviews
Finally found a really good pizza place in Ft Myers. Friendly staff and good food. We ordered the veggie pizza. Chicken parm hero and a large cheese pie.and meatball appetizer. Entire family... More
First time here. Beer was cold and the large pizza was ginormous! Lots of toppings and sauce. Our waiter Beany took good care of us. We will definitely be back! More
Being raised in Queens NY I am a bit of a pizza snob. I have yet to have a slice of pizza that Is nearly as good as a NYC slice, but Poppy's is my Fort Myers choice when craving pizza. The crust... More
Pretty good, not great. Pizza was really oily and salty for us. But it's pizza-- sooo ... lol. The crust was really tasty but a little tough. We ordered carryout, the employee who took our order... More
Great handmade pizza. They even gave me the sausage choice of sliced or crumbled for my topping. Friendly staff. More
