Selenia M.04/04/24I can't believe this is my first time trying the pizza. I'm a New Haven native and I've visited this plaza more than I can count. I don't know if I ever visited as a child, but I don't think... More
Adrian N.08/31/23You guys get a 8/10 Food meaning the pizza was great. Prefer a bit more crispy.counter people were great. The place just got a renovation but felt somewhat of a weird vibe. Service was great. More
Meghan W.12/03/22You know this place has been here a long time when the last yelp review is from over a year ago, with most being over 3 years old. We came for pizza and enjoyed it. tasty sauce, fresh mushrooms,... More
Bonnie S.10/14/23Great pizza, This pizzeria that has been in Hamden for years. Fair pricing too! The employees work hard and they stay open the hours they post. Bought a pizza recently where they were near to... More
Dave R.10/08/21I've been gone from the area a decade, so I'm happy writing this bit of terrible news. Di Matteo's has the best cold pizza in the entire world. When I lived there, by the end of it, I would not... More