Seth J.02/17/24Best kept secret in Verona/Montclair area. Have been there for lunch only so can't comment on dinner. Prices are great as is quality and service. For lunch we had Manhattan and New England... More
Peter K.06/09/23Was going to visit the place next door, but I saw this place and the packed tables so I went in. Boy was I glad! It's a fish market turned restaurant, full of locals who love seafood. It's similar... More
Jim S.06/24/23The seafood here was excellent. Everything was fresh. The owner/chef comes around to each table to make sure everything is perfect with his guests. Very good seafood pasta dishes better than... More
Steven D.05/25/23Anthony has created a enduring menu with some of the best fish & chips in the area his specials are creative especially the beet and burrata salad which is large enough for two to share when in... More
Ninfa Q.12/29/23Well, let me tell you, Caldwell seafood is absolutely amazing! From the moment I tried it, I was blown away by its exceptional quality and performance. The flavors are so rich and delicious, and... More