Angie Y.09/30/18Tucked away in a little hole in the wall on main st. is solid ny style pizza and affordable prices. If you're looking to not get ripped off by master pizza that dictates most of west orange and... More
Mort C.12/10/22Here's a quick review of a childhood favorite of mine! I grew up in West Orange, NJ, and unfortunate circumstances brought me back into town. Johnny's Pizzeria was old haunt us kids used to... More
Jerry D.11/18/22Stopped by here to have a slice and try them out. The slice was okay, nothing to boast about. Thin crust, cheese and sauce were okay. More
Nathan R.01/01/23To be honest, pizza taste is a personal thing. For me I like the old Brooklyn style pizza - thin crust, delicious sauce and not overly cheesy or doughy. Johnny's delivers on that. I can eat 5... More
S A.06/13/22Nice thin crust and real mushrooms not the gross canned ones. Orders are hot and ready quickly and the pizza even stands up to my drive home to Jersey City! Friendly staff, a real gem. More