The Critical J.08/05/23PROS: very nice toy shop that has all of the latest themes. Ranging from cartoons to pop culture. Staff is nice and everything is priced well CONS: it's cramped inside so if there's a lot of... More
Christine A.12/21/19Cute shop that has a bit of everything and most likely a magical expanding spell considering all the merchandise sold there Worth a pop in More
Ginny P.08/11/19Visited Cape May this weekend and was appalled at items being sold at The Toy Shop of Cape May. A display of wooden guns, everything from handguns to assault rifles with scopes, are near the front... More
Christopher K.09/02/13Another incarnation of the small, carefully curated, slightly overpriced, mom and pop toy store. You know, the type that inevitably pop up in trendy locations frequented by pushover parents and... More
Karen T.06/20/11This store has the unique toys and the most friendly staff. Get really busy around 7 to 10pm. More