Lynnsey O.03/29/24Great experience today at Costello's!! The staff were very friendly and welcoming. The size of the slices were very very big!!!! I feel our slices were not hot enough they could have been in the... More
Noah S.04/21/24The place was completely CROWDED, pizza was done but it took 13 minutes to get to me. Once we got it and left, ALL the cheese fell off. My little cousin started crying. More
Tracey G.10/10/23Walked in To grab a menu,and was told they had no menus avbl and to go online so we went online to their website looked thru that found 2 subs we thought would be good (my husbands boss always... More
Rich P.07/22/23Pizza was VERY VERY GOOD! Great undercarriage with zero flop. Great taste with crispy crust. Friendly staff and Pizza delivered to table nice and HOT. More
Kristina K.03/31/22Overall the salad wasn't bad but not great. About 20% of the lettuce was yellow. The onions were very large and cut thick. The chicken, cucumbers, and tomatoes were fresh. No cheese - no hard boil... More