Mueller's Bakery specializes in old fashioned quality and customer service. We are a full line retail bakery using...
Website: muellersbakery.com
Phone: (732) 892-0442
Cross Streets: Between S Park Ave/Club Dr and Lake Ave
80 Bridge Ave Bay Head, NJ 08742 473.50 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.5 182 reviews
Yet another great bakery one of the few left in the area. It's well worth the trip. A little out of the way but the town parking lot across the street always has spots. More
I love this spot for their sugar cookies - it's nostalgic and reminiscent of the cookies I had growing up. I've also tried a few of their pies and cakes, and they're quite good. When it comes... More
We bought their crumb cake that everyone raves about. It was all crumb and very little cake. Disappointing. Delponte's bakery in Bradley Beach is still the best in my book. More
We love Mueller's coffee cake! We bring it to my great-grandmother's house every year. This week, we celebrated my grandparents' 50th wedding anniversary, and we bought a cake from Mueller's for... More
Mehhhhh. The coffee was not good and the cup was scalding. The cheese ring was 8 out of 10, a tad bit too sweet. My husband said the powdered jelly donut was awful. My daughter loved the... More
