Quin R.05/13/24The pizza here had exceptional quality flavors. They also have a great variety of food options beyond just pizza. Would for sure eat here again. More
Christyl J.11/11/23Place is small with just enough seating. Super busy when I came in, lots of delivery pizzas being made between people dining in. I noticed everyone getting pizza, but decided to get the grilled... More
Jill D.09/09/23Before road tripping, we decided to stop in town for a quick gran n' go bite. After two other delis were closed due to their vacationing week, we stumbled into Main Street Pizza. With plenty if... More
Ant R.02/19/23Wasn't expecting much here, but the options are terrific. ~Detroit Style ~Philly Cheesesteak Style ~Veggie (Just to name a few) The Detroit style was especially good; that burnt cheese on... More
Justin L.10/17/22One of the biggest things you need in any town in the NY metro area is a solid hometown pizza place. Without that, there is little point to living here. For Tarrytown, that place seems to be... More