Search results
- See moreSee moreSee moreSee morePizza SupremePizza · $
Pickup · Delivery
678 Stewart Ave Garden City, NY 11530 496.88 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
Amenities
- Family friendly
Pickup · Delivery
678 Stewart Ave Garden City, NY 11530 496.88 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.5 92 reviews
Love their square pizza. Moved to Florida miss them so much Going to ny in august. Planning on having pizza every day!!! Bruce More
Square pizza is the best around. Been coming here for almost 20 years, when my parents used to bring me. I'm sure the rest of the pizza matches the quality of the square slices, but I just can't... More
I used to like this place and we used to go all the time.Recently I ordered a pizza pie and it tasted pretty bad. The cheese wasn't gooey enough and the sauce tasted weird. Never will be coming... More
Might be the worst pizza I've ever had. The sauce was bitter and watery. The guys who work there were nice, but I will not be returning, unfortunately. More
I'm a Pizza enthusiast and accustomed to the good Pizza available in the boroughs of NYC. So, take that into account when considering my opinion. I was disappointed with the round pie. Crust was... More