Full Service Fish Market and Restaurant specializing in the freshest seafood local and from around the world!
Website: thefishstoreonline.com
Phone: (631) 472-3018
836 Montauk Hwy Bayport, NY 11705 526.19 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.5 89 reviews
Absolutely consistent, a true old fashioned fish shop located and nestled alongside Montauk hwy Bring a cooler unlike me lol They'll give you ice From platters ( shrimp, lobster, crab) to take... More
The food was great & very reasonably priced. Our server (Angela) was very nice. I've gone for takeout before and also shopped in the fresh seafood market before. Will definitely be back to dine in... More
I have been buying fish here for over a decade. The fish is always fresh, and most are locally caught. They have everything from blow fish to striped bass. Now they have a sushi chef, making... More
In all honesty, I smelled the fish as I walked to the front door. I was taught, if you can smell the fish, you don't want it. Upon entering the smell of the fish slapped me terribly. My gag... More
Came here for restaurant week because it was one of the more diverse menus. It's a small place at the back of a fish store, but no wait on a weekend night so big plus for us! The service was... More
