Rick T.01/02/24Stopped on way through town day after New Year's Day. Friendly staff...one of the best sandwiches I've ever had! Thoroughly enjoyed the Italian Grinder and wife had veggie quesadilla which she... More
Ken L.12/03/23A reasonable place off 28 where there is not a lot going on. We stopped on our way to Cooperstown and had a very good meal. Our waitress was a little clueless, but I think they hire local high... More
Ron R.12/04/23Went to Phoenicia for a nice bike ride. My friend recommended this pizza and wanted to order two pies for the three of us, I thought he was nuts. Then the pizza with sesame seed crust landed on my... More
Melissa H.02/22/24We love getting pizza and calzones from Brio's in Phoenicia. We discovered it our first night in Phoenicia-- walking distance from the Black Bear Campground. How awesome to be able to walk and get... More
Victor J.02/13/24Attentive service. Menu filled with the greatest hits - chicken parm, fajitas, burgers, meatloaf, steak sandwiches, Caesar salad, assorted cakes ... and Hands Down Low Key coolest Bar Stool... More