Tina L.01/10/24BEST PIZZA IN PUTNAM COUNTY!! If you haven't been here yet you don't know what you are missing! Owners are amazing and hard working, Regina is always so sweet. The food is ALWAYS amazing, but the... More
Paul C.07/07/22Great family operated restaurant, Love the home cooked food! Great customer service, great staff! More
Elizabeth C.03/31/19I'm not big on pizza, but I've ordered for family or friends who have come over to visit and they like it. I just wished they would deliver. More
C M.07/27/16Two stars because of friendly service and ok pizza. The meatballs and lasagna were very bad! I don't know why it has more than 4 stars. Besides the place is not clean and organize so it makes you... More
Joe G.12/14/15Great food great service. Owners Paul and Regina, have created a Family friendly atmosphere and are always happy to see you. Putnam Lake pizza has truly been a big part of the Putnam Lake... More