Barbie B.03/28/24It's my goal to try out all the pizza places in Central NY. Oliveri's is a stand out - friendly staff and a warm little cozy place probably does a lot of business in takeout. They do a good crust... More
Kathleen S.03/11/24A huge shoutout to Oliveri's Pizzeria. They catered a lunch for about 75 people for the Hamilton Central School musical. Mike is a joy to work with, thorough and generous. And the food, as always,... More
Timothy T.12/23/23One of the best small town pizzerias of central NY, hands down. I grew up in upstate NY and this features some of the best pepperoni and anchovy pizza I've had south of Utica. The staff is... More
Patrick S.11/08/23Great pizza, great people, great place. Best in Madison County coming from a person who grew up in NYC. More
Tom F.04/28/23For 2 slices and a soda this is a iconic deal for $7.50. Pizza had some of the the best sauce! If you like thin & crispy; this is the pizza for you. No pictures because it was too delicious. Quick... More