Website: thepizzaheist.com
Phone: (716) 681-1111
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Aurora St and Como Park Blvd
Pickup · Delivery
231 Aurora St Lancaster, NY 14086 300.41 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.5 62 reviews
I feel like this is hands down the best pizza in Lancaster. They never miss! We try different places all the time but we keep coming back here. Easily on par with Grassos, perhaps better... More
Super clean interior, friendly cashier at the register. Perfect presentation on the pizza, sauce is on the sweet side and it had the perfect amount of cheese. Pizza logs, well they're pizza logs.... More
Pizza Heist has decent pizza for great prices. A tomato paste tasting sauce with a good amount of cheese. Two slices are about $5. You can't beat that pricing anywhere in Lancaster! My biggest... More
Their chicken finger pizza is absolutely the best in town. Lots of chicken, perfect amount of cheese and blue cheese as the base! Delicious. More
Pizza was good, I like that the crust isn't paper thin. Could use a sprinkle of oregano on top though. But the cleanliness of the place is questionable. Ceiling fans had cobwebs on them, garbage... More
