Signature Frozen Custard, Handmade Ice Cream & All Natural Roast Beef on Weck!
Website: andersonscustard.com
Phone: (716) 875-5952
2235 Sheridan Dr Buffalo, NY 14223 297.85 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.0 117 reviews
Always delicious. Love the lemon ice, probably my favorite flavor- the lemon which is the traditional, original ice! As with so many places, prices have gone up, but the associates are always... More
Worst milkshake I've ever had. I've ordered their custard-based milkshakes a few times and their consistency is hit or miss. I've had some that were pretty thin, but still had some resistance... More
Even if the food served here was terrible, you'd have to give stars for nostalgia alone. If you lined up a short list of western New York institutions, Anderson's would be on it and this original... More
Covid update: They are on the DoorDash app for easy online ordering! Select pick up to avoid delivery charges if you prefer Recently ordered some apps and ice cream and dang it was good More
Visiting from out of town and can't believe how bad the food is here now. Nothing like it used to be. The kimmelweck roll had maybe 4 caraway seeds and 4 specks of salt, the beef was over cooked,... More
