Cori R.08/04/16Always a go-to when I come into town! Love the pizza, wings, Pudgie burger, etc.... Love dipping the pizza in the wing sauce, can't ever go wrong. The price seems kinda steep, but like anyone one... More
Connor M.02/12/24Horseheads Pudgies has pretty good pizza, wings and subs. The negatives are that everything is pretty expensive on the menu... I mean $1.25 for a little cup of blue cheese and to say the least... More
Susan J.10/22/23One of the worst pizzas I've probably ever had. I asked for a supreme pizza, and since I don't like sausage, I asked them to replace the sausage with more pepperoni. He didn't tell me there would... More
Drake D.08/06/23Good pizza sometimes it's to doughy sometimes it's perfect but I have mixed emotions about it but the wing sauce yummmmmm More
Yembur A.04/23/21Short and sweet: the standard cheese pizza is actually quite tasty, but the veggie toppings (namely mushroom and onion) are not that great. I tried the fries as well, which were mediocre. With... More