McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe has been a staple in Erie, PA since 1978. Our family owned restaurant is best known for our...
Website: msm290.flavorplate.com
Phone: (814) 866-0552
Cross Streets: Between W 38th St and Oakwood St
1624 W 38th St Erie, PA 16508 209.09 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.5 62 reviews
Overall, it was a great experience. . Pros- Service was friendly, knowledgeable, helpful, and pleasant. 100% happy with our server. Awesome menu variety. Very nice food portions. Loved the... More
There is a reason they are voted best Reuben in Erie. They never disappoint. Tried fried fish and a steak salad this time- fish batter was still soggy, ew, and one of the salad tomatoes was... More
Best Rueben in all the land! The host/owner made us feel welcome and my annual visit home to the area delicious. Everyone in my family was totally happy with their meals. More
For the longest time I would always order a reuben here because they are so well known for it and it's amazing. Recently, I decided to try something new. And oh my gosh, I have been missing out on... More
Ordered the meatloaf, verified it was 'homemade'. It was not good. Not consistent in color. Took a bite and pushed it to the end of the table. The waitress never asked about it and clearly saw I... More
