Zachary P.11/10/23Walking in you are immediately greeted by a big smile and the smell of heavenly pizza. If you're here to grab a bite, take home a tray, or sit down with that special someone you will find it here.... More
Natalia F.10/13/22This place is off the main drag but for a good reason! Mary Lou herself still works the oven with her sons and grandsons and shares the building with some of her family's own businesses. The... More
Josh B.03/24/23Ran out of round pizza shells by 3:30, ordered a square red instead with peppers. It was crunchy to the point where I thought it was burnt until I checked underneath and the peppers were near... More
Tony S.08/25/23Great service. Clean atmosphere. Excellent pizza. Wish we had time to order a few more items off the menu. Worth the detour during a recent trip to NY! More
Ron G.06/26/22The year was 2015. I had just started dating my now wife who is from the Scranton area and, knowing I am a pizza lover, she brought me to Old Forge and said This is the pizza capitol of the... More