Gloria C.10/25/20Yummm! What a hole in the wall! My favorite type of places! FYI, this place is located in a gas station in the corner of a slightly remote town. I was here in Shenandoah on a mini getaway... More
Michelle H.08/10/23HUGE disappointment. HUGE! The only pizza they make is a combination and a pepperoni. WTH??? Mind you, there's a banner behind the counter that identified allllllll sorts of specialty pizzas. The... More
Dewakar S.02/23/23Squicky clean, pizza was awesome, great service. Would definitely come back again! Would highly recommend this place More
Yvette M.01/09/23The Owner is an amazing person.....Doesn't know me, but allowed me to get a Pizza, I am SOOO impressed......I will ONLY get Pizza at Godfathers when I'm in New Market.....AMAZING CUSTOMER... More
Carla B.06/08/22Great pizza, made to order. Complicated system of paying with the gas station that houses the pizza shop. More