Jeff N.01/13/24We ate there on Thursday night. The 4 of us ordered a large antipasto salad and 2 Trenton Tomato pies. We both had half mustard pies with toppings. The best!! Service is good and the place is... More
Maulik M.03/08/24I heard from a friend that there was a Trenton-style pizza (but also a mustard pizza), I knew I had to make the long drive to Papa's. I really liked the sweet chunkier pizza sauce with small... More
Carrie H.01/12/24We've heard a lot about this pizza place so while we were in the area we gave it a shot Ordered one mustard pie with sausage and one plain with pepperoni I thought the crust was delicious and... More
Michele D.12/23/23Ok, imho, don't go out of the way for this mustard pizza. I thought maybe there would be some slight spin on the sauce or in the dough, but it's just mustard squirted back and forth over the pie.... More
Richard R.03/23/24Perfect pizza every time. thin crust, great sauce, no flop. The mustard pie is a thing of wonder. Every topping is top flight, the salads are awesome. Papa's is old school. Simple, consistent,... More