We are locally owned and operated and specialize in fresh baked Key Lime pie every day for our visitors.
Phone: (305) 296-9515
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Greene St and Telegraph Ln
424 Greene St Key West, FL 33040 1069.57 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
5.0 20 reviews
The key lime pie was good, but a little bit too tart. It was also a bit pricey for the size slice you get. Overall enjoyable and satisfying. More
We walked to the address of this store and it is no longer in existence. But a few doors down the street is The Key Lime Factory. More
We stopped at this place and tried a piece of all three pie types-key line, coconut key lime and coconut creme. They make them all fresh in the store. The staff was very friendly. There are many great... More
I have tried key lime pie all over the keys, and most definitely all around Key West, and theirs is the very best! Creamier and more flavorful, I found it better than the others! The store offers a... More
Their ice cream is so good! One scoop of coconut, topped with one scoop of key lime. My favorite dessert (besides the Key Lime Martini at Alonzo's $4 during Happy Hour) in Key West!!! More
