David B.02/23/24This review has taken me some time to complete but looking back I had to write about it. This establishment is at the top end of steakhouses that northwest Ohio has to offer. I visited Old City... More
Andy C.12/06/22Found this gem on YELP and so glad I stopped. John is an amazing owner and Scott was an excellent server. Very friendly and attentive. Great staff. Food wedge salad extra yummy. Nice... More
Laura K.10/18/23This is probably the best steakhouse in Lima and surrounding area. The food was delicious and service was as expected; top notch. I had the filet medium rare and salty, warm bread served with... More
Jon D.03/21/24Have been to Old City several times and it is usually good. Thia trip was different. Ordered filet mignon at $56.00, a price which would indicate you're going to get a nice piece of meat. My filet... More
Lisa R.05/22/23The food was excellent. We ordered lobster tails, salmon, steak, etc. The only comment I would make is our waitress was a bit bland and slow. Also the beef stroganoff was under cooked when we... More