Susan B.04/24/24Delicious calzone with fresh vegetables and tasty crust! We also had excellent service for our large party! More
Lance H.05/12/24Ahh, classic pizza joint, the best. Perfect cbus style pizza, Ice, and I mean ICE, cold beer, super friendly and attentive staff, delicious fresh salad, crunchy fries, nice burger and warm gooey... More
Ronda D.04/16/24I've been here several times before . I love the pizza here and the crust is always crispy and amazing!! The staff were a bit preoccupied with talking at the bar area and we waited for their... More
Joe F.04/01/23Visiting Buckeye Lake for the weekend. My friend and I were looking for a place to grab dinner and heard great things about Pizza Cottage. The restaurant was busy when we arrived and it was a... More
Amy B.09/11/23A great location for us when staying at the KOA @ Buckeye Lake. The menu had a lot of great options and some unique dishes. We got the whole hog pizza (thin crust which is their normal crust)... More