Everything at Mary Zifer Pizza is made from scratch daily. We use no preservatives in anything. Our sauce, salad...
Phone: (330) 343-1188
Cross Streets: Between Fair Ave NW and Ashwood Ln NW
145 2nd St NW New Philadelphia, OH 44663 88.33 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
4.5 11 reviews
I had an extended wait for food. They were very busy. I got 2 Meatball Splashes, 1 salad with House Vinegar and Oil, A family size Rigatoni and Family Size Spaghetti. What I ate tonight was... More
Great local pizza shop! Love the pizza and salad with the homemade dressing it's soo good! More
Mary Ziffers pizza is a local owned pizza shop that makes a sweet thicker crust pizza that is absolutely fantastic !! All ingredients are fresh so each pizza is made as they are ordered . The... More
I have never had a bad experience here. They are a little deficient in the customer service department, but you call in and place your order, pay and pick it up. No big deal. They can get pretty... More
Not worth the hassle. Crust is very dry & tastless, sauce/cheese not memorable, limited topping choices & most annoyingly, DON'T TAKE CREDIT CARDS OR DELIVER!!! Plus the staff lack customer... More
