Website: butterfingersbakery.com
Phone: (219) 924-6464
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of 45th St and Spring St
2552 45th St Highland, IN 46322 258.08 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
3.5 55 reviews
Love Butterfingers! Awesome box lunches that are made fresh and fast! Whenever I'm in the area and want a damn good sandwich I swing in at either this or the munster location. Cakes and... More
Wonderful Chicken Salad sandwich! The half sandwich was just enough for me! Finished my lunch with the mini pecan pie and it was delish! More
Great treats ( we've had cupcakes and most of the bars) with a surprise side car of the best chicken salad I've had. Always a pleasant staff. More
Very overpriced. $20 for a half cake and they don't even have boxes to fit a half cake so they put it in a whole cake box and even after placing the cake on the floor of the car to avoid tipping,... More
I don't think I've had anything bad there. Top Notch! Favorites are the cakes, chili, stuffed peppers n chicken breast. Get the boxed lunch, great value. Some things may seem pricey but the... More
