Nancy S.04/11/24We ordered delivery via Grub Hub. This was our first order from Panatieri's. We thoroughly enjoyed the food, but I am holding off one star since we haven't tried the pizza yet. The food arrived... More
Kirsten K.07/24/23The pizza here is exceptional! I love the huge variety of slices and how creative the toppings are. Yes I am team pineapple on pizza, and they have that here! My current favorite topping is the... More
TJ U.10/03/22Best pizza in surrounding area of Warren, NJ. Consistently good and have several great options if you don't want pizza. I continue to go back because of the staff. Natalie is The best! More
Joelle Z.02/05/23So, I ordered a pizza tonight for pick up and was there in 10 minutes to pick it up and it wasn't hot at all. I don't know about you, but I like my pizza to be hot. I did notice the box wasn't hot... More
Jin H.06/21/21The food is standard, but we've been ordering from here throughout the pandemic, and they keep forgetting items in our order. Almost every time we order one thing is missing. They either didn't... More