David W.11/09/23Stopped in for a pizza and we were not disappointed. I have been craving NJ pizza for years since moving west and this place did not disappoint. They have a full menu and plenty of seating. We... More
Patti R.02/07/24I went again and had my raw oysters and for the first time, ordered their chips made in-house. Once I added a bit of salt to the chips, they were good and had good crunch. Additional photos added. More
Hank C.08/27/23Similar to the one over by Morristown, this Godfather has a special for buy 2 pies, get third 1/2 off. They used to do buy 2 cheese, get one free, I think, but that was pre-pandemic. Not sure if... More
Patricia M.08/28/23I love the Godfather. There are two sections, one that is dining and the other self-seating. We usually order at the counter and sit ourselves. It is extremely clean and the service is always... More
Pat M.02/22/23I've been going to The Godfather since the early 90's and fortunately, not much has changed. This is still one of, if not the best, pizzerias in East Hanover. There's always a wide variety of... More